Town of Stony Plain Sanitary Sewer Condition Assessment Program

The project involves the condition assessment of four sanitary sewer segments from the Town of Stony Plain's recent CCTV inspection programs, applying Avodahtec's in-house Risk and Condition-Based Assessment Framework to identify structural risk and recommend clear next steps.

CLIENT
Town of Stony Plain
PROVINCE
Alberta
TIMELINE
May to June 2025
Town of Stony Plain Sanitary Sewer Condition Assessment Program project image

Project Overview

The Town of Stony Plain commissioned a CCTV inspection of selected storm and sanitary sewers, with all inspection work and reporting completed in accordance with the NASSCO Pipeline Assessment Certification Program (PACP) standard. To demonstrate the value of its Risk and Condition-Based Assessment Framework for Sewers, Avodahtec invited the Town to share a sample of this data for a pilot assessment. The Town provided CCTV inspection data for four 200 mm segments. The segments range in age from 12 to 66 years and include both vitrified clay (VCP) and PVC pipes. The assessment found a Grade 4 or 5 defect roughly every 17 m of inspected pipe, with significant structural distress in all four segments and the older VCP mains most severely affected.

Project Scope Snapshot

Sanitary Network

4 Sewer Segments

Four 200 mm VCP and PVC segments built between 1959 and 2013, with 1.9 m to 3.7 m of cover

Data Reviewed

CCTV & PACP Data

CCTV footage, PACP inspection reports, and as-built drawings

Standards

NASSCO PACP

NASSCO PACP condition grading and Quick Ratings

Assessment Method

PCOF & SSR Scoring

Avodahtec's Probable Contributor of Failure (PCOF) and Structural Severity Rating (SSR) scoring

The Challenge

About 30% of the network could not be inspected. On one segment, the survey was abandoned after only 16 m when a broken pipe with visible soil blocked the camera, leaving the remaining 89 m unassessed and likely in worse condition. The defects also differed by material, with brittle fractures and joint failures in VCP and deformation in comparatively young PVC pipe. Standard pipe rating indices, which average in low-severity defects, suggested the sewers were in fair condition. The Town needed an assessment that would surface the critical defects hidden in that average and support timely, defensible decisions before failures escalated.

Technical Challenge

About 30% of the network could not be inspected. On one segment, the survey was abandoned after only 16 m when a broken pipe with visible soil blocked the camera, leaving the remaining 89 m unassessed and likely in worse condition. The defects also differed by material, with brittle fractures and joint failures in VCP and deformation in comparatively young PVC pipe.

Strategic Challenge

Standard pipe rating indices, which average in low-severity defects, suggested the sewers were in fair condition. The Town needed an assessment that would surface the critical defects hidden in that average and support timely, defensible decisions before failures escalated.

Our Approach

1. Data Intake & Review

We compiled the CCTV footage, PACP reports, and as-built information for each segment, documenting age, material, depth, and location.

2. Defect Analysis

We quantified structural, operational, and maintenance (O&M) defects by type, grade, and frequency, and documented representative defects using CCTV imagery.

3. PACP Rating Analysis

We calculated structural and O&M pipe ratings, rating indices, and Quick Ratings, showing how Quick Ratings revealed priorities that the averaged indices concealed.

4. PCOF & SSR Scoring

We applied our modified PCOF and SSR scoring to filter out low-severity noise (Grades 1 to 3), identifying all four segments as requiring attention and two VCP segments as requiring immediate attention.

5. Engineering Failure Analysis

We explained the likely failure mechanisms for each pipe material and linked them to Stony Plain's variable glacial and lacustrine soils, groundwater fluctuation, freeze-thaw cycles, and traffic loading.

6. Recommendations & Remediation Options

We recommended an Engineering Design Evaluation and Stability Assessment as the immediate next step, supported by a defect-specific matrix of repair and renewal options.

What Made This Project Successful

Value from Existing Data

The pilot turned inspection data the Town already owned into decision-ready insights, with no new fieldwork required.

Signal Over Noise

PCOF and SSR scoring exposed critical structural defects that averaged rating indices had masked.

Engineering Insight, Not Just Scores

Linking each defect to material behavior and local ground conditions explained why the sewers were failing, not only where.

Clear Priorities for Action

Segment-level priorities and a defect-specific options matrix gave the Town a practical, proactive path forward.

A Scalable Framework

The pilot demonstrated a repeatable approach that can grow into a full risk-based prioritization of the Town's sewer network.

Related Services and Insights